Google vs AI search for law firms: what our Manchester study found.
We analysed 378 Greater Manchester law firms across Google and a defined sample of AI answers. The results show why ranking in search and being named by AI are two different visibility problems.
For years, law firm search visibility has been relatively easy to picture.
A prospective client types a problem into Google. The search engine returns a list of pages. The firms that rank highest get the best chance of being considered.
AI search changes the shape of that journey.
Instead of asking only which page ranks, a potential client can ask an assistant which firm or solicitor they should consider. The answer is generated rather than ranked, and the firms or people named can be different from those dominating a traditional results page.
Findwell tested both routes in the first Manchester Law Firm Visibility Index.
We analysed 378 active law firms registered in Greater Manchester across Google and a defined sample of web-enabled AI answers. The results do not prove that one channel is replacing the other. They do show that being visible in Google and being named by AI are different problems.
Google and AI do not create the same kind of result.
The most important difference is structural.
Google ranks pages.
An AI assistant generates an answer.
That sounds obvious, but it changes what a law firm is competing for.
In Google, a firm can occupy one position among many. A searcher can scroll, compare several websites, open a directory and build their own shortlist.
In an AI answer, part of that comparison happens before the user visits a website. The system selects which firms, sources or individuals to mention in the response.
| Google search | AI answer |
|---|---|
| Ranks pages | Generates an answer |
| Shows many competing results | Selects a smaller set of sources or names |
| Visibility is strongly page-based | Visibility can be firm-, source- or person-based |
| Position is directly observable | Inclusion can vary by prompt and model |
| A user builds the shortlist | The answer can pre-filter the shortlist |
This does not make Google less important.
It means law firms now have at least two visibility questions to answer: 'Where do we rank?' and 'When somebody asks, do we get named?'
What our Google sample returned.
For the firm-level part of the Manchester index, Findwell ran 18 searches based on the type of legal work a client might need and classified 465 Google results.
The results were overwhelmingly firm-led.
A further 13% were directories, legal rankings, news or other third-party pages.
Pages centred on a named individual accounted for fewer than 2% of the Google results measured.
That distinction matters.
Traditional law firm SEO has become very good at creating pages around services, practice areas and locations. Those pages can tell Google that a firm handles employment law, family law or conveyancing in Manchester.
They do not necessarily tell a prospective client which person inside the firm is known for a specific problem.
That is why a standard team biography and an expert profile page built around a person's expertise do different jobs.
One confirms who works at the firm.
The other can connect a named person to the subjects they write about, the media they appear in, the questions they answer and the evidence of their expertise across the web.
What our AI sample returned.
The AI part of the index asked who to instruct across the practice areas measured.
Across 36 answers, the models named just 32 firms registered in Greater Manchester in total.
At least one of the 378 firms in the study appeared in 81% of those answers.
In the remaining 19%, the model either pointed the user towards a directory or named a national firm outside the Greater Manchester register used for the study.
This is not a universal ranking of AI visibility.
The test used two web-enabled Claude models in September 2026, with a defined set of prompts. A different model, wording, date or location can produce different results.
That is exactly why Findwell treats AI visibility as a separate discovery channel rather than an extension of traditional Google rankings.
The useful finding is not that 32 is a permanent number.
It is that the AI sample narrowed a market of 378 registered firms down to a much smaller set of names.
A high Google position does not guarantee AI visibility.
The overall Manchester index makes the difference particularly clear.
Some firms performed strongly in Google across several practice areas but received few or no AI mentions in the sample.
Others had a narrower Google footprint but were named comparatively often by AI.
For example, the top 10 visibility ranking included firms with very different combinations of:
- high Google positions
- breadth across practice areas
- AI mentions
The result is a useful warning against treating "visibility" as one metric.
A law firm can be:
- easy to find in Google but rarely named by an AI assistant
- visible in AI answers without owning the broadest Google footprint
- strong at firm level while its individual lawyers remain difficult to retrieve
- visible for one specialist subject and absent from another
There is no single number that captures all four.
The gap gets more interesting when you ask for a person.
Findwell also tested person-level questions.
Instead of asking which law firm to instruct, the prompts asked for individual solicitors.
Across 68 answers, AI named an individual in 63% of cases and produced 114 different people in total.
Only 41 of those people worked at firms registered in Greater Manchester under the rules of the index.
The finding should not be read as "AI prefers individuals to firms" in every context.
The prompts were different, and the firm-level and person-level tests answer different questions.
What it does show is that AI systems can retrieve people even when traditional search results remain heavily dominated by firm-level pages.
That creates a new visibility problem for law firms.
A firm may have a strong service page and still have no obvious named expert associated with the question a buyer asks.
Why the difference matters for law firm SEO.
For years, law firm SEO strategy has quite reasonably focused on pages that capture demand.
A user searches:
- employment solicitor Manchester
- family law firm Manchester
- conveyancing solicitor Manchester
The firm builds a page that targets that need.
That remains useful.
But AI discovery introduces another layer:
Who is the person behind the answer?
A model looking across the web can encounter:
- firm service pages
- expert profiles
- authored articles
- legal directories
- media coverage
- conference pages
- videos
- third-party citations
The more clearly those sources connect the same person to the same subject, the easier it becomes for a system, journalist or prospective client to understand what that expert is known for.
This is also why our law firm content strategy starts with topic ownership rather than an empty content calendar.
A firm does not simply need more pages.
It needs clearer relationships between people, subjects and evidence.
Google visibility and AI visibility should be measured separately.
One of the easiest mistakes is to treat AI visibility as another search ranking.
It is not.
A useful law firm measurement framework should separate at least four things.
Google visibility.
Track:
- rankings for relevant non-brand queries
- impressions and clicks
- breadth across priority practice areas
- pages attracting discovery traffic
AI firm visibility.
Track:
- whether the firm is named for relevant prompts
- which models name it
- how often it appears across repeated tests
- which sources are cited alongside the answer
Individual expert visibility.
Track:
- whether named solicitors surface for their subjects
- branded searches combining the person and topic
- visibility of their expert profile and authored content
- media and third-party references around the same expertise
Commercial outcomes.
Track:
- enquiries influenced by search or AI
- visits from research content into expert or service pages
- assisted conversions
- whether the right practice areas are generating demand
What other 2026 research suggests.
Findwell's Manchester dataset is intentionally local and limited to the methodology in the index.
Other 2026 law-firm studies have reached a similar conclusion on one important point: AI platforms do not behave identically, and Google visibility is not a reliable proxy for being named everywhere else.
Gregg King's UK study, for example, compared Google, ChatGPT and Perplexity and found materially different firm sets across the platforms.
That does not validate every finding in our Manchester sample, because the methodologies are different.
It does reinforce the case for measuring channels separately rather than assuming that a strong Google position automatically carries across to every AI system.
What law firms should do differently.
The answer is not to abandon SEO and start optimising for an unknowable algorithm.
It is to make the firm's expertise clearer in more places.
Three priorities follow from the data.
Keep competing for high-intent Google searches.
Practice-area and service visibility still matter because buyers continue to search by problem and location.
Make individual expertise easier to retrieve.
A named partner should have more than a short team biography. Their public record should make it clear which subjects they know and provide evidence around those subjects.
Build consistent evidence across owned and third-party sources.
Articles, video, expert pages, media commentary and external citations all contribute to the public record around a person and a topic.
Our guide to AEO for law firms goes deeper into how expert-led content can become easier for answer engines to retrieve and use.
Google versus AI is the wrong final question.
The useful question is not whether Google or AI wins.
Law firms need to be discoverable in both.
Google remains a major route into legal research, and firm-level search positions are already highly competitive.
AI adds another route in which the answer itself can filter the market before a user arrives on a website.
The Manchester data suggests those two systems do not surface expertise in exactly the same way.
For law firms, that means visibility needs to be built at two levels:
the firm needs to be findable for the work, and the right people need to be findable for the expertise behind it.
See how Findwell helps law firms build visibility across search and AI
See your experts, found.
A 30-minute walkthrough, tailored to your firm, of where your experts would rank and what it would take.